Show me:
and
Clear all filters

  • 35 items
  • 25 items Explore
  • 89 items
  • 3,544 items Explore
  • 97 items Explore
  • 263 items
  • 4 items
  • 220 items
  • 13,345 items Explore
  • 209 items Explore
  • 1,225 items Explore
  • 8,753 items Explore
  • 5,075 items Explore
  • 62 items Explore
  • 165 items Explore
  • 13,005 items Explore
  • 13,617 items Explore
  • 4,811 items Explore
  • 1 items
  • 5 items
  • 149 items Explore
  • 2,006 items Explore
  • 4,759 items Explore
  • 437 items Explore
  • 266 items
  • 102 items Explore
  • 19,976 items Explore
  • 34 items Explore
  • 1,917 items Explore
  • 1,083 items Explore
  • 5 items
  • 2,107 items Explore
  • 2 items
  • 456 items Explore
  • 920 items Explore
  • 1 items Explore
  • 5 items
  • 7 items
  • 20,353 items Explore
  • 800 items Explore
  • 19 items
  • 73 items Explore
  • 33 items
  • 793 items
  • 20 items
  • 4 items
  • 26 items
  • 61 items
  • 28 items
  • 319 items Explore
  • 6 items
  • 44 items Explore
  • 1 items
  • 2 items
  • 2 items
  • 7 items
  • 121 items Explore
  • 119 items
  • 1 items
  • 935 items Explore
  • 813 items
  • 95 items
  • 27 items
  • 107 items
  • 37,427 items Explore
  • 1 items
  • 3,881 items Explore
  • 1,535 items Explore
  • 403 items
  • 125 items Explore
  • 10,425 items Explore
  • 9,684 items Explore
  • 4 items
  • 1 items
  • 38 items
  • 3 items
  • 4 items
  • 6,779 items Explore
  • 2 items
  • 7,364 items Explore
  • 4,691 items Explore
  • 1,911 items Explore
  • 1,194 items Explore
  • 23,713 items Explore
  • 3,663 items Explore
  • 17 items
  • 5 items
  • 334 items
  • 1 items
  • 1 items
  • 3,354 items Explore
  • 23 items Explore
  • 374 items Explore
  • 796 items Explore
  • 1,095 items Explore
  • 514 items Explore
  • 1,146 items Explore
  • 89 items
  • 125 items Explore
  • 6,955 items Explore
  • 76 items
  • 109 items
  • 4 items
  • 2 items
  • 63 items
  • 2 items
  • 2,909 items Explore
  • 1,582 items Explore
  • 203 items
  • 90 items
  • 22,212 items Explore
  • 1,329 items Explore
  • 138 items
  • 847 items Explore
  • 32 items
  • 1 items
  • 130 items Explore
  • 40 items
  • 20 items
  • 252 items
  • 313 items
  • 685 items Explore
  • 346 items Explore
  • 2,429 items
  • 2,544 items
  • 3 items
  • 1 items
  • 1 items
  • 4,393 items Explore
  • 40,350 items Explore
  • 1 items
  • 3,293 items Explore
  • 275 items Explore
  • 8,778 items Explore
  • 31 items
  • 25 items
  • 304 items Explore
  • 778 items Explore
  • 3 items
  • 65 items
  • 161 items
  • 50 items
  • 52 items
  • 23,509 items Explore
  • 916 items
  • 66 items
  • 22,644 items Explore
  • 2 items
  • 2,337 items Explore
  • 1 items
  • 1,028 items Explore
  • 4 items
  • 759 items
  • 499 items
  • 4 items
  • 3,309 items Explore
  • 179 items
  • 59 items
  • 454 items Explore
  • 3 items
  • 21 items
  • 90 items Explore
  • 76 items
  • 281 items Explore
  • 1 items
  • 6 items
  • 128 items
  • 295 items
  • 447 items
  • 289 items
  • 1 items
  • 906 items Explore
  • 272 items Explore
  • 221 items
  • 11,296 items Explore
  • 755 items Explore
  • 6,030 items Explore
  • 2 items
  • 8,298 items Explore
  • 27 items
  • 1 items
  • 5,977 items Explore
  • 4 items
  • 3,725 items Explore
  • 9,182 items Explore
  • 7,888 items Explore
  • 185 items
  • 19 items
  • 144 items
  • 7 items
  • 853 items Explore
  • 19 items
  • 8 items
  • 1,096 items Explore
  • 270 items
  • 1 items
  • 2,078 items
  • 3,543 items Explore
  • 695 items Explore
  • 18 items
  • 134 items
  • 6,742 items Explore
  • 95 items
  • 18,939 items Explore
  • 3,136 items Explore
  • 3 items
  • 7 items
  • 10,979 items Explore
  • 37 items
  • 2 items
  • 21,448 items Explore
  • 35 items
  • 13,292 items Explore
  • 3,462 items Explore
  • 5,660 items Explore
  • 33 items
  • 50,894 items Explore
  • 4 items
  • 646 items Explore
  • 417 items
  • 26,946 items Explore
  • 216 items
  • 3 items
  • 6 items
  • 1 items
  • 35 items
  • 27 items
  • 445 items Explore
  • 636 items
  • 217 items Explore
  • 13 items
  • 13,667 items Explore
  • 1,360 items Explore
  • 3 items
  • 10,260 items
  • 9 items
  • 10 items
  • 14 items
  • 25 items
  • 1 items
  • 4,528 items Explore
  • 913 items Explore
  • 1 items
  • 1 items
  • 314 items
  • 511 items Explore
  • 42 items
  • 2,290 items Explore
  • 1,664 items Explore
  • 15 items
  • 1,876 items Explore
  • 150 items
  • 81 items
  • 766 items Explore
  • 3,137 items Explore
  • 44 items
  • 17 items
  • 12 items
  • 10,669 items Explore
  • 23,468 items Explore
  • 3 items
  • 1 items
  • 41 items
  • 1,374 items
  • 179 items Explore
  • 8 items
  • 84 items
  • 1 items
  • 13,584 items Explore
  • 3,582 items Explore
  • 2,904 items Explore
  • 4,798 items Explore
  • 22 items
  • 30 items
  • 6,910 items Explore
  • 4,841 items Explore
  • 256 items Explore
  • 2,300 items Explore
  • 2,978 items Explore
  • 2 items
  • 1,897 items Explore
  • 191 items
  • 223 items Explore
  • 466 items Explore
  • 6,118 items Explore
  • 8,729 items Explore
  • 1,860 items Explore
  • 3 items
  • 1 items
  • 5,940 items Explore
  • 3,354 items Explore
  • 11,129 items Explore
  • 1 items
  • 84 items
  • 11 items
  • 2,545 items Explore
  • 7 items
  • 24 items
  • 51 items
  • 6 items
  • 1 items
  • 4,262 items Explore
  • 611 items Explore
  • 72 items
  • 17 items
  • 154 items Explore
  • 1 items
  • 95 items Explore
  • 458 items
  • 996 items Explore
  • 3,554 items Explore
  • 4 items
  • 5 items
  • 2 items
  • 9,539 items Explore
  • 48 items Explore
  • 3 items
  • 7 items
  • 42 items
  • 3 items
  • 13,790 items Explore
  • 4 items
  • 1,161 items Explore
  • 92 items
  • 10,561 items Explore
  • 1,920 items
  • 18 items
  • 6,835 items Explore
  • 21 items
  • 12,951 items Explore
  • 1,418 items Explore
  • 8 items
  • 6,173 items Explore
  • 14,895 items Explore
  • 4 items
  • 1,667 items Explore
  • 181 items Explore
  • 4 items
  • 15 items
  • 5,686 items Explore
  • 12,284 items Explore
  • 48 items
  • 25 items
  • 2 items
  • 3 items
  • 7,216 items Explore
  • 357 items Explore
  • 13 items
  • 6 items
  • 103 items Explore
  • 7 items
  • 5 items
  • 485 items
  • 667 items Explore
  • 8,367 items Explore
  • 58 items
  • 7,347 items Explore
  • 5 items
  • 26 items
  • 4,615 items Explore
  • 428 items
  • 339 items Explore
  • 12,715 items Explore
  • 55 items
  • 20 items
  • 7 items
  • 4 items
  • 325 items Explore
  • 427 items
  • 458 items
  • 1 items
  • 3,703 items Explore
  • 27 items
  • 1,238 items Explore
  • 2,503 items Explore
  • 734 items Explore
  • 36 items
  • 1,139 items Explore
  • 97 items Explore
  • 24 items
  • 228 items Explore
  • 80,098 items Explore
  • 1 items
  • 3,136 items Explore
  • 2,874 items Explore
  • 25 items
  • 5,350 items Explore
  • 1,831 items Explore
  • 4 items
  • 17,515 items Explore
  • 4,930 items Explore
  • 1 items
  • 7 items
  • 631 items Explore
  • 85 items
  • 31 items
  • 1 items
  • 76 items
  • 29 items
  • 86 items
  • 3 items
  • 1,176 items Explore
  • 109 items
  • 805 items
  • 12,585 items Explore
  • 27 items
  • 13 items
  • 1,709 items Explore
  • 214 items
  • 17,037 items Explore
  • 85 items
  • 17 items
  • 1 items
  • 8 items
  • 324 items
  • 2 items
  • 626 items Explore
  • 1,597 items Explore
  • 8 items
  • 1,130 items Explore
  • 373 items
  • 2 items
  • 343 items

Select a time period

Or choose a specific year

Clear all filters

Catherine Bruce, Mrs William Murray (d. 1649)

attributed to Peter Besnier (fl.1643, d.1687-93)

Category

Art / Sculpture

Date

circa 1637 - 1639

Materials

Bronze

Measurements

785 x 540 x 340 mm

Place of origin

England

Order this image

Collection

Ham House, Surrey

NT 1139887

Summary

Bronze, Catherine Bruce, Mrs William Murray (died 1649), attributed to Peter Besnier (fl. 1643, died 1687/88), c. 1637-9. A bronze portrait bust of Catherine Bruce, Mrs William Murray, mother of the Countess of Dysart, attributed to the Anglo-French sculptor Peter Besnier (fl. 1643, died 1687/88). The bust depicts the sitter wearing a loose silk robe embellished with floral decoration, that slightly falls from and exposes her right shoulder. Her left arm passes across her front to hold the edge of the robe, to prevent it from falling further. She gazes upwards and slightly to her right. Mrs Murray’s luxuriant hair cascades down each side of her head in loose curls, whilst at the back it is plaited and coiled into a tight bun, held in place by an accessory in the form of a collar of pearls. The bust is fixed by means of three tangs to a separately made socle with scrolled supports, at the centre of which is the Bruce coat-of-arms, a tree issuing from an earl’s coronet.

Full description

The bust is extremely carefully finished, with for example hammering to the sitter’s robe, and the use of a minute punch to stipple the hair and the background of the coat-of-arms. The metal is a brass alloy, with copper (c. 75%) mixed with a high level of zinc (c. 20%) and other smaller quantities of other metals, in particular lead and iron (XRF analysis by Rupert Harris Conservation, April 2011). The bust has in the past often been described as gilded, but in fact this is incorrect. All the brightness is in the metal, the high-zinc brass copper alloy used. The bust formerly had a black lacquer surface, removed by the Victoria & Albert Museum in around 1980. The assumption made at the time of the removal that this was a later covering may not in fact have been correct. The bust is recorded in successive Ham House inventories, in 1677 as above the chimneypiece in the White Closet, its position today. The 1683 inventory identifies it as a portrait of Catherine Bruce, Mrs William Murray, the mother of Elizabeth, later Duchess of Lauderdale. Catherine Bruce was of Scottish birth, daughter of Colonel Norman Bruce and a kinsman of the Earl of Elgin. In around 1626 she married William Murray, a close friend of the future King Charles I since childhood and an ardent royalist supporter, who was heavily engaged both during and after the Civil War in assisting the monarch and his wife and attempting in vain to broker a settlement between Charles and the Scots. Catherine was a lady-in-waiting to Queen Henrietta Maria. During and after the Civil War, she and her four daughters remained mostly in residence at Ham, which was transferred by her husband into her name. She indomitably resisted attempts by the Parliamentary Commissioners to seize the house and suffered numerous fines and other tribulations. William Murray was created Earl of Dysart in 1643, although he did not take up the title until 1751 so that, on her death in 1649, Catherine Murray was recorded without the title on her coffin plate (NT 1139995). The Murrays’ eldest daughter Elizabeth married firstly in 1648 Sir Lionel Tollemache and, subsequently, John Maitland, second Earl of Lauderdale. This exceptional portrait, one of the finest sculptures to survive from the period before the English Civil War, represents the highest level of portraiture in bronze in Britain at this time. It has sometimes been attributed to the French sculptor Hubert Le Sueur (c. 1580-1658), who is first recorded in England in 1626 and worked as sculptor to King Charles I until the Civil War. A competent caster but with little artistic imagination, Le Sueur’s bronze portrait busts, which include images of King Charles I at Stourhead (NT 731855) and Edward Herbert, 1st Baron Herbert of Cherbury at Powis Castle (NT 1181001) appear somewhat flaccid when compared with the vigorous image of Catherine Bruce. It has recently been suggested that it is likely to be the work of another Anglo-French sculptor, Peter Besnier. Peter and his brother Isaac worked for king Charles I before the Civil War and, at the Restoration in 1660, Peter petitioned the new king Charles II for reinstatement to his old position. Confirmation that Peter Besnier did indeed cast in bronze comes from the advertisement he placed in 1663 for sculptures stolen from him, described in the advertisement as ‘one blackmore cast from the life, and three or four other heads’ (Adam White, ‘A Biographical Dictionary of London Tomb Sculptors c, 1560-c. 1660. Addenda and Corrigenda’, The Walpole Society, 71 (2009), pp. 325-355, pp. 329-30). The bust has close stylistic resonances with a pair of plaster busts of Sir William and Lady Fermor, now in Northampton Museums and Art Gallery, which have been attributed to Peter Besnier. The two Fermor busts are placed on bases of similar form, whilst the turn of Mary Fermor’s head, her décolleté dress and the handling of her hair all have parallels with the bust of Catherine Murray. Peter Besnier is also likely to have made the large plaster figures of Mars and Minerva above the Chimneypiece in the Hall at Ham House (NT 1139652.1 and 2), sometimes thought to be idealised images of William Murray and his wife. It has been proposed (Avery, ‘Seventeenth-Century Sculpture at Ham House’) that the Besnier family may well have made much of the extant sculpture at Ham House, including the large series of lead and plaster busts of Roman emperors and other figures. Catherine Bruce was painted for her portrait by Anthony van Dyck in 1637-38, around the same time that the bronze bust was made. The prime version of van Dyck’s portrait is at Petworth House (NT 486240), whilst there is a copy of a variant version at Ham House (NT 1139939). Van Dyck’s portrait. Van Dyck’s portrait of Catherine Bruce may have been one of the sources for the sculptor of the bronze bust, although the superbly modelled elaborate bun of hair at the back of Mrs Murray’s head seems quite different from the arrangement in Van Dyck’s Petworth portrtait. One of the most distinctive features of the bronze bust is the inclusion of the sitter’s left arm, which reaches across to hold on to one end of the drapery wrapped loosely around her. Whilst this feature derives ultimately from Classical portrait busts of women, it was used in the sixteenth and seventeenth century for a series of intimate portraits of women, beginning with Titian’s haunting portrait of c. 1535 depicting a young girl partly dressed in a fur, the edge of which she holds onto. Now in the Kunsthistorisches Museum in Vienna, at the time that the bronze bust was made, Titian’s portrait was one of the highlights of the collections of King Charles I. When he visited London in 1629-30, Peter Paul Rubens copied Titian’s painting, which served as the starting point for his large portrait known as The Little Fur, which shows his second wife Helene Fourment standing completely nude except for a fur around her midriff (c. 1636-38, Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna). In around 1638, Anthony van Dyck, perhaps responding to Rubens, reprised Titian’s image for his portrait of his mistress Margaret Lemon (Royal Collection). Whilst the bronze portrait bust of Catherine Bruce is more restrained than Ruben’s or Van Dyck’s images, it seems to form part of this sequence of intimate and slightly suggestive images. The sitter does not, as in her portrait by Van Dyck, wear a chemise below the rich drapery which seems to be some form of wrap rather than a dress, whilst her right hand seems clearly to be holding onto one end which, if it were allowed to drop, would cause the drapery to fall, thereby revealing her breasts. The bust of Catherine Bruce is likely therefore be to have been a rather private commission on the part of the Murrays but, at the same time, like the copies at Ham of great paintings then in the collection Charles I, it may also be seen as a more subtle homage to another great painting by Titian in that collection. Jeremy Warren December 2021

Provenance

Commissioned c. 1637-39 by Catherine Bruce, Mrs William Murray, and her husband William Murray; identifiable in the Ham House inventories of 1677, The White Closet: ‘One brasse head over ye Chimney’; of 1683, The White Closet: ‘One brasse head of her Graces mother’; of 1728, Garden Closet: ‘a Blackmoors Head over the Chimney’; identifiable in the addendum of 1741, the Green & Gold Closet: 'NB The Brazen Busto, ye Dutchess of Lauderdales Mother Mrs Catherine Murray’; identifiable in the Ham House inventory of 1844, Round Gallery: ‘a fine Bronze Bust of the mother of the Duchess of Lauderdale’; thence by descent, until acquired in 1948 by HM Government when Sir Lyonel, 4th Bt (1854 – 1952) and Sir Cecil Tollemache, 5th Bt (1886 – 1969) presented Ham House to the National Trust. Entrusted to the care of the Victoria & Albert Museum until 1990, when returned to the care of the National Trust, to which ownership was transferred in 2002.

Credit line

Ham House, The Dysart Collection (purchased by HM Government in 1948 and transferred to the National Trust in 2002)

Makers and roles

attributed to Peter Besnier (fl.1643, d.1687-93), sculptor Hubert Le Sueur (c.1580 - Paris 1658), artist

Exhibition history

The Treasure Houses of Britain, National Gallery of Art, Washington, USA, 1985 - 1986, no.68

References

Esdaile 1935 K. Esdaile, 'Herbert Le Sueur', Burlington Magazine LXVI, 1935, p. 177, Pl. IIc Avery 1980: Charles Avery, ‘Hubert Le Sueur, the “Unworthy Praxiteles” of King Charles I’, The Volume of the Walpole Society, vol. 48 (1980): 135-209, pp. 190-91, no. 52, Pl. 61d. Jackson-Stops 1985: Gervase Jackson-Stops (ed.), The Treasure Houses of Britain: five hundred years of private patronage and art collecting, exh. cat. The National Gallery of Art, Washington, New Haven and London 1985, no. 68. Rowell 2013: Christopher Rowell (ed.), Ham House, 400 Years of Collecting and Patronage, Yale University Press, New Haven & London 2013, Charles Avery in Chapter 12 'Seventeenth-Century Sculpture at Ham House', pp. 158-177 Rowell 2018 Christopher Rowell, ‘Women Artists, Collectors and Patrons’, National Trust Historic Houses & Collections Annual, 2018, pp.6-7

View more details